Solvable Extensions, p-cyclic over Other Characteristics

p-cyclic over Other Characteristics

In the last section we described p-cyclic extensions of K when the characteristic of K was p.  In this section we will describe p-cyclic extensions of K when the characteristic is not equal to p.  Instead of the polynomial xp-x-a, we will use the polynomial xp-a.

Let F = K(u), where up = a, for some a in K.  Thus u is a root of xp-a, a polynomial that is, by assumption, irreducible.  Note, sometimes K is the fraction field of a ufd, and a is a nonunit in that ufd, divisible by some prime factor q, but not q2, whence the polynomial becomes irreducible by eisenstein's criterion.

Assume there is an element r in K that is a primitive pth root of 1.  Thus K contains all the pth roots of 1, and splits xp-1.

The elements u, ur, ur2, etc, are the p distinct roots of xp-a, so F splits a separable polynomial, and is galois.  The size of the galois group G is the dimension of F/K, which is the degree of our irreducible polynomial, which is p.  The only group of order p is cyclic, hence F/K is a cyclic extension of order p.

Conversely, let F/K be a cyclic extension of order p.  Let r be a primitive pth root of 1 as described above.

If a field, any field, contains rj for some nonzero j, raise this to the m, where m is the inverse of j mod p.  The result is r.  Thus our (generic) field contains all the powers of r.  One conjugate brings in the rest.

If F contains r, and r is not in K, then K(r) is an intermediate extension of dimension p-1 inside F.  Since F/K has dimension p, this is impossible.  So if r is in F, it lies in K.

If r is not in F then adjoin r to create a larger field E.  All the conjugates of r are present, E is a splitting field, and E is normal over F.

Think of E as K adjoin (F and the powers of r).  Since F is a splitting field, and the powers of r form another splitting field, E is a splitting field over K.  The associated polynomials are separable, hence E/K is galois.

The galois group of E/F is cyclic, generated by the automorphism r → rj, where j is primitive mod p.

Let's try to get a handle on the galois group of E/K.  Let c generate the cyclic galois group of F/K.  This is an automorphism on F, and it can be extended to a field homomorphism from F(r) onto F(rj), since r and rj are conjugates.  (Remember, j is a primitive root mod p.)  Now this homomorphism is really an automorphism on E/K.  Call this automorphism d.

What is the order of d inside the galois group?  We must invoke d p times before F gets back to where it started.  Thus the order of d is divisible by p.  At the same time, the root r must return to its original position.  Thus the order of d is divisible by p-1.  Since p and p-1 are coprime, |d| = p×(p-1), which is the order of the group.  The galois group is cyclic.

What is the norm of r in E/K?  Let L = K(r), and take it step by step.  The norm of r in L/K is the product of the conjugates, which is 1.  Raise this to the p power to get |r| in E/K.

Since |r| = 1, apply the trace/norm theorem, and there is a nonzero w in E with w/d(w) = r.  Since d(w) is not equal to w, w does not lie in K.  Let u = 1/w, so that d(u) = ur.

Notice that d fixes up, hence up lies in K.  In other words, u is the pth root of a, for some a in K.

The subgroup generated by the automorphism dp has order p-1 in the galois group G, and fixes an intermediate extension of dimension p.  Yet d is based on c, and cp fixes F.  So dp fixes a field of dimension p, and it fixes F, hence it fixes precisely F, and nothing more.  Since dp fixes u, u is in F.

The field K(u) cannot be intermediate between K and F, since the dimension of F/K is prime; therefore K(u) = F.  The polynomial xp-a is irreducible over K.

Since F is galois, it splits the separable polynomial xp-a.  This means F contains all the conjugates of u, which are all distinct.  Take the quotient of any two conjugates and raise this to the p power.  The result is 1.  Thus F contains a pth root of 1.  If F contains r then K contains r (we showed this earlier).  So K contains r after all.  We didn't need to "adjoin" r; it was there all the time.

In summary, let K be a field whose characteristic is not p.  The extension F/K is cyclic of order p, iff K contains a primitive pth root of 1, and F = K(u), where u is a root of the irreducible polynomial xp-a, for some a in K.