Subdirect Products, Little Ideal

Little Ideal

A little ideal is a nonzero ideal that is contained in every nonzero ideal of R. If R has a little ideal, the intersection of any set of nonzero ideals is nonempty, and R cannot have a nontrivial subdirect product. Conversely, if all nonzero ideals intersect in 0, let each act as a kernel Ki, and build the nontrivial subdirect product representation Si = R/Ki. Thus R is subdirectly irreducible iff it has a little ideal.

If R is a division ring, or even a simple ring, R is subdirectly irreducible.

The direct product of two or more rings is never subdirectly irreducible. Intersect the ideals R1*0 and 0*R2 and get 0.

Dedekind Domain

A dedekind domain does not have a little ideal (the square of such an ideal is smaller), hence it is not subdirectly irreducible. For a nontrivial representation, map R onto R/Mj for M a maximal ideal and arbitrarily large exponents j. The intersection of this descending chain of kernels is 0, so R embeds. Alternatively, map R onto R/M for infinitely many maximal ideals M. Nothing can be in all these ideals at once.

Mod out by Mj, and R/Mj becomes subdirectly irreducible. The little ideal is the image of Mj-1.

Semisimple

If R is semisimple, it is subdirectly irreducible iff it is the direct product of only one simple ring. We already said direct products are out, and a simple ring has its one and only ideal as a little ideal.

Group Ring

If R is not subdirectly irreducible then neither is the group ring RG. Let Ki be a collection of kernels of R that intersect in 0. Let these act as coefficients on the elements of G, whence KiG become ideals in RG that intersect in 0.

Prime Ring

Let R be prime with nonzero socle H. We will show H is a little ideal, whence R is subdirectly irreducible. Let I be any ideal and let M be a minimal left ideal. Since I*M is a left ideal inside M, and since I*M is nonzero (R is prime), then I*M = M. Of course I*M lies in I since I is an ideal, hence I contains M. This holds for every M, hence I contains H.

The converse does not hold. Let R be simple, which Implies R is prime. Assume R is not left artinian. Being simple, R is subdirectly irreducible. Its socle H is either 0 or R. Suppose it is R. Then a finite sum of elements, from a finite set of minimal left ideals, equals 1. These are simple left ideals, and simple modules are pairwise disjoint. Thus R is the finite sum of simple left ideals, R is a semisimple ring, and R is left artinian. This is a contradiction, hence H = 0. A prime ring can have a 0 socle and still be subdirectly irreducible.

K[x]

If K is a division ring that is nonalgebraic over its center, K[x] is left primitive. Since it is a left pid, any ideal can be squared to get something smaller. There is no little ideal, and the ring is not subdirectly irreducible.

Reduced and Commutative

If R is reduced and commutative, it is subdirectly irreducible iff it is a field. Let x lie in the little ideal. Since x2 is not zero, it generates the same little ideal, hence x2*y = x for some y. Multiply through by y, and (xy)2 = xy. Remember that x2y = x, and x is nonzero, hence xy is a nonzero idempotent. There can be no nontrivial idempotents, else R is a direct product of rings, with no little ideal. Thus xy = 1, x is a unit, and the little ideal is all of R. There can be no smaller ideals, other than 0, hence R is a field.